We grade the report, not the claimant.

Every diagnosis, test score and conclusion in a psych report gets checked against the published research. Every weak answer gets flagged, explained in plain English, and turned into a question for deposition.

Free quote. No fee if we can't review it.

Dr Ron Heredia, smilingDr Ron
NamePsych PQME report, 62 pages
Use No. 2 pencil only
Click or drag to fill in bubbles

Dr Ron has spoken on psych claims at RIMS RISKWORLD, National Comp, PARMA and SCFIA. He sits on HIRMA's advisory committee, and his training is approved for CLE in seven states.

Could you spot the flaw?

Five statements from a fictional psych report. Pick an answer for each, and see how we would mark it in a Consultation Report.

Question 1 of 5

"The applicant meets criteria for Major Depressive Disorder, with low mood, poor sleep and fatigue."

This statement is:
Pick an answer.

Answer: B. Not supported: DSM-5-TR needs five of nine symptoms

Why it doesn't hold up

Three symptoms are listed. DSM-5-TR requires at least five of nine, present together for two weeks. A diagnosis the data can't support is not substantial medical evidence.

Ask at deposition

Doctor, which five of the nine criteria did you document?

Where in your report is each one recorded?

Question 2 of 5

"Elevated F-r is consistent with the applicant's significant distress."

This statement is:
Pick an answer.

Answer: B. Misread: F-r is a validity scale that flags possible over-reporting

Why it doesn't hold up

F-r exists to flag over-reporting. When it is elevated, the test manual warns the profile may not be interpretable. Calling it distress turns a red flag into a symptom.

Ask at deposition

What is the F-r scale designed to measure?

What does the manual say about a profile with this score?

Question 3 of 5

"No prior psychiatric history."

This statement is:
Pick an answer.

Answer: C. Contradicted: prior records show treatment for anxiety before the injury

Why it doesn't hold up

The records show treatment before the claimed injury. Leaving it out skews causation and apportionment.

Ask at deposition

Did you review the prior treating provider's records?

If not, how did you rule out a pre-existing condition?

Question 4 of 5

"The interview was conducted via secure video platform."

This statement is:
Pick an answer.

Answer: B. Raises questions: who was present and how testing was supervised can't be verified

Why it doesn't hold up

A remote evaluation can't confirm who else was in the room, whether testing was supervised, or the behavioural cues an in-person exam would catch.

Ask at deposition

How did you confirm no one else was present during testing?

Which publisher guidelines permit remote administration of this test?

Question 5 of 5

"Causation is 100% industrial."

This statement is:
Pick an answer.

Answer: C. Not enough: no reasoning given and no other causes considered

Why it doesn't hold up

An opinion has to explain how the doctor reached it. A bare percentage, with no other causes discussed, doesn't meet that bar.

Ask at deposition

What other causes did you consider?

Why did you rule out each one?

Read the scales the doctor skipped.

Psych tests come with built-in checks for exaggeration and inconsistency. We read every one, and show you when the doctor didn't.

Over-reporting range, T 100+ 50 100 F-r 108 "distress"?? No. Over-reporting. VRIN-rTRIN-rF-rFp-rFsFBS-rRBSL-rK-r
Sample validity profile, fictional scores

Where's your case right now?

Send it over. We'll tell you whether it's worth challenging and what a Consultation Report will cost.

No fee if we can't review it.

You get a cross-examination strategy and a script of simple questions that put every flaw on the record.

Usually two to three weeks. Rush available.

No cross-examination coming? The report gives you what you need for a trial brief or a petition to the judge.

Clients use it to seek dismissal of an IME, PQME, AME or treating doctor's report.

A numbered list of flaws, backed by the research, is leverage. Show opposing counsel why the report won't stand up.

Negotiate from evidence, not instinct.

Dr Ron can testify, with exhibits, a pre-trial conference and travel to the trial location.

CV and fee schedule on request.

How it works

Directions

  1. Send the report. Email it with a short cover letter about the case and your concerns.
  2. Get a quote. Cost depends on the number of diagnoses and tests. If we can't review it, we'll say so, and there's no fee.
  3. We grade it. Diagnosis, testing, history and method, each checked against the published research.
  4. Walk in prepared. You get the flaws, the science and a script of questions. If the case goes to trial, Dr Ron can testify.

Usually two to three weeks. Rush service available. Every report is work-product privileged.

Dr Ron Heredia

Dr Ron Heredia

Ron teaches psychology for a living. He turns dense clinical reports into plain language that attorneys, adjusters and juries can follow.

DoctoratePepperdine Graduate School of Education & Psychology
DegreeBA Psychology, UCLA
TeachesPsychology, East Los Angeles College
AdvisoryHIRMA committee
Comments

"Dr. Ron Heredia is easily the most helpful and knowledgeable expert I have had the opportunity to work with."

Ashley Mohammadi, Associate Attorney, Mullen & Filippi, LLP

Read Dr Ron's full background

Free CLE for your whole team.

Twelve talks on reading psych reports, spotting faked symptoms and deposing the doctor. In person or online, at no charge.

See the course list

Got a psych report that needs grading?

Send the report with a short note about the case. We will tell you whether it is worth challenging and what it will cost.

Send us a reportFree quote. No fee if we can't review it.